PVBL: Punxatawney Groundhogs
Final Report Card

October 9, 1999

Anchorage AK (AP) - The Abominations 1999 season was filled with a lot of interesting developments. Coming into the season, the 'Boms had set their sights high and plagued with numerous injuries and roster moves, as well as the infamous missing mascot's feet incident, the Abominations fell well short of their goals for the season. Despite a record that was identical to the previous season, Anchorage seemed to make some strides in the right direction. Lets score the ballclub from the Great Northwest:

Catchers:
Mike Lieberthal: B-, Mike came on strong at the end of the season, but was plagued with injuries throughout the year and only managed to hit 17 home runs. The Abominations were counting on more pop from his bat after dealing both Vaughn and Bichette. Was outstanding defensively, committing just two errors in 123 games.

Chuck Lynn: B, Chuck did a great job filling in for the injured Lieberthal throughout the season, as well as playing almost exclusively versus lefties. Six homeruns in 172 at-bats provided good pop for the team. Strike out total of 26 was a bit high, but he was solid behind the plate, with just one error in 72 games.

Irv Strange: Incomplete, Irv only played in four games when Lieberthal was on the DL.

Overall Catchers: B, catcher was possibly the most solid position on the team, with the exception of shortstop.

Firstbase:
Mark Grace: B+, acquired mid season from the New Diggens Budweiser Frogs, Mark managed to rejuvenate his career. Came to Anchorage hitting a miserable .237. The Abominations made the committment to start him everyday and he raised his play, finishing the season hitting .276 with 13 homeruns and 57 RBIs. Mark was flawless defensively, committing no errors all season.

Al Tavarez: Incomplete, played just one game, down the stretch when the season was lost.

Overall Firstbase: B+, Anchorage could use someone with a bit more pop at first, but with Grace's unbelievable defense, the position is at the very least solid.

Secondbase:
Miguel Cairo: C-, Cairo was being counted on to be a leadoff hitter at the beginning of the year, but he quickly faded to the bottom half of the order after struggling through a number of injuries. Miguel batted just .250 for the year and had just 511 at bats. He struck out 78 times and walked just 17 times, not a good ratio for a leadoff hitter. Miguel was very solid defensively, committing just two errors in 126 games. Anchorage will be looking for much more from Cairo in 2000.

Mark Lemke: F, plucked from free agency, Lemke filled the gap left by the departure of Luis Alicea in the midseason deal for Mark Grace. Lemke played in just 17 games, batted just .209, and committed 7 errors for a .811 fielding average. Needless to say, do not expect to see Mark in a Abomination's uniform next season.

Overall Secondbase: D, when the infield was out with injury, Anchorage had no where to turn. Look for the 'Boms to pick up a backup in the offseason. Miguel Cairo is still one of the building blocks of this franchise, and Anchorage will rely on his development heavily next season.

Thirdbase:
Jeff Cirillo: A-, Jeff Cirillo was brought in to be the franchise player for the Abominations and he came through, when he was healthy. Plagued with injuries on and off during the season, Cirillo matured into the best unknown infielder in the PVBL. Jeff hit .320 with 19 homeruns 65 RBIs and 101 runs created. He slugged .500 and did a good job defensively, with just seven errors in 138 games. Cirillo is another of the Abominations' building blocks.

Overall Thirdbase: B+, Cirillo is one of the best, but what if he gets injured again?

Shortstop:
Mark Grudzielanek: B, Grudzielanek was brought in after the 'Boms dealt free agent Omar Vizquel for Jeff Cirillo. Mark had a strong season, but tapered off toward the end after the Abominations had nothing to play for. He batted a solid .285, but seemed to bat better in the lower half of the lineup. His 14 errors led the team, but that's bad. Again, a solid performer in the infield that was prone to injury.

Gary DiSarcina: B-, DiSarcina was a utility infielder for the 'Boms, filling in where needed much of the year. Gary played short, second, and third for the 'Boms. Subject of many trade rumors throughout the season, he held on as the Abominations best bench player.

Overall shortstop: B+, good depth, good talent. Should be solid for years to come.

Rightfield:
Tony Gwynn: C-, hit just below career numbers, Tony seemed uncomfortable in the starting role. Went down with an injury late in the year. Tony may retire, but will probably be a backup next year.

Willie McGee: B-, Willie is the consumate pro. A clubhouse leader and veteran, Willie played exceptional late in the year when the youngsters seemed to give up. Nick Tulach is praying that he decides to stick around for one more year.

Overall Rightfield: D, a real lack of talent here. The Abominations need to plug the hole left by Sheffield's departure. They had Alex Ochoa, but he wasn't a fit. They had Dante Bichette, but he didn't fit either. Look for the rookie Geoff Jenkins to move here or a possible free agent acquistion.

Centerfield:
Brian McRae: B, Brian was a definate upgrade at center for the Abominations. The duo of Santangelo and Javier was not cutting it. Brian was solid defensively, with no errors in 118 games, and provided good pop from the plate, batting .280 with a .405 slugging average. He also swiped 15 bases.

Stan Javier: C-, a true utility player with a true off year. Stan batted just .221 but did lead the team in triples with two. Still, he is a solid veteran who is great in the clubhouse. Look for him to remain.

Overall Centerfield: B-, if Javier can bounce back from an off year, this position is pretty solid. Look for status quo.

Leftfield:
Cliff Floyd: C+, Floyd came in mid-season replacing the aging greg Vaughn in left. Floyd was solid defensively, but his offensive number tapered off late in the season. He is still young and the Abominations are counting on him developing into more of an offensive threat. The jury is still out on this one.

Ivan Calderon: B+, Ivan was another mid season free agent acquisition who made a signifigant contribution to the team. Taking over the backup position in right field and left, Ivan slugged his way to a team-best .544 slugging percentage. Hitting .294 for the season, Ivan was a pleasant surprise in an otherwise disappointing outfield.

Rickey Henderson: C, another veteran who is past his prime, Rickey may call it quits and take over the managing duties of the team from Nick Tulach.

Overall leftfield: C, if Floyd can develop into a power threat, then this position is servicable. There is always Geoff Jenkins waiting in the wings.

Designated Hitter:
John Jaha: A-, a great replacement for Eric Karros, Jaha made waves by recording 100 RBIs for the year. He also managed to hit .305 with 34 homeruns and was the lone real power threat in the Anchorage lineup.

Overall DH: B+, if Jaha wasn't here, this team might challenge Medina for record losses.

Starting Pitching:
Mike Bottenfield: C, the number one guy for the entire season, Bottenfield was the first Abomination in history to record 10 wins in a Anchorage uniform. A great pickup from Vero Beach, look for Mike to improve again next season. A 4.69 ERA was a bit high, but he only gave up 16 homeruns and didn't miss a start all year.

Scott Aldred: B-, a mid season acquisiton, Scott quickly established himself as the number two starter. Recording a 12-6 record with a 3.76 ERA, Aldred was solid, but somewhat inconsistent. Regardless, he will be relied on to post comparable number next season.

Willie VanLandingham: B, the best pitcher that no one has heard of, Willie was seriously hurt when he wasn't selected to the All Star game. A 2.81 ERA, giving up just 117 hits in 144 1/3 innings, Willie was a near ace in an ace-less staff. Some question his durablility, but he is penciled in as the number one guy next season.

Bobby Jones: B, the closest thing to an ace on this staff, Bobby was acquired mid season and is a possibility for number one starter next season.

Ariel Prieto: C-, posted ten wins for the season, but his 5.27 ERA and .311 opponents batting average are sub-par. May be on his way out.

Buddy Moisan: D, Anchorage dealt a lot to get this youngster. They are praying that it pays off. If he develops some more control during the off season, look for him to break into the starting rotation.

Steve Tsamis: D, didn't give up a lot of hits, but struggled with his control. He might have a future somewhere, but it probably won't be Anchorage.

Overall Starting Pitching: C, some good performers, but overall will need a better effort to compete with the likes of Galena and Ann Arbor

Relief Pitching:
Billy Wagner: D+, Wagner had a definate off year. The 'Boms were counting on him to anchor what was thought to be a solid bullpen. He was the focal point of the problems in 1999.

Don Wengert: F, the other big blunder by Tulach. He didn't notice that this guy was destroying games for his team till it was too late. He will not be back in 2000.

Scott Service: C+, a solid body in the chaotic bullpen, Service provided good middle and setup work throughout the season.

Marc Wilkins: C-, a mid season acquisition, Marc mainly came in to relieve in lost situations. He will provide depth in case of injury next season.

Mike Holtz: C+, gave up toward the end of the year, Holtz was erratic for most of the season. A team leading 18 holds, he will remain a setup man for the 'Boms next year.

Eddie Guardado: B-, the only real above average player in the pen, Guardado posted 20 saves, despite a 4.44 ERA. His 39 strikeouts in 50 2/3 innings was a bright spot. Might be trade bait, but most likely will remain the Abominations' closer.

Vaughn Eshelman: C-, Vaughn was a backup that filled in when Billy Wagner was injured. He'll be in the same role next season.

Terry Werden: C-, gave up far too many homeruns. Werden snuck into the pen late in the year for Wengert and pitched well for a bit. Went south late in the year.

Bob Torres: Incomplete, picked off the free agent list, Torres was insurance against further injury. Might make the team next season, but shouldn't hold his breath.

John Tankersley: Incomplete, came over from the Bums in the Bichette deal. Anchorage is hoping he develops into a solid reliever.

Overall Relief Pitching: D, what was thought to be a strong point turned out to be a serious weakness. Need to add at least one more arm to the pen. Ake and Danforth should fit nicely when they develop into big league material.

OVERALL: D+, made some good moves later in the season, but blunders early might have closed the door on the ability to compete in the near future. Tulach will give them one more year to see progress and then it'll be a rebuilding effort for Anchorage. Perennial cellar-dwellers it seems.

--written by Dan Shapiro